“The book was better” might be the most reliable sentence in film history.
Usually it’s true. Books get hundreds of pages; films get two hours and a budget. But every so often, an adaptation understands its book, keeps what matters, changes what cinema needs changed, and becomes a classic in its own right.
These seven are my picks, whether or not you’ve read the originals. Every entry is spoiler-free, with what the film keeps, what it changes, and the order I’d recommend. This list pairs nicely with our roundup of hidden gem movies you probably missed but shouldn’t, and a couple prove the point of our list of 10 movies from the 90s that are still worth watching today.
1. The Princess Bride (1987) — William Goldman
William Goldman adapted his own novel, and it shows in every line. The film keeps the book’s best invention: the story-within-a-story, with a grandfather reading an adventure tale to his reluctant, unwell grandson, interrupting at exactly the moments a child would interrupt.
What it keeps: the wit, the warmth, and nearly all the famous dialogue, because Goldman knew which of his lines were load-bearing. What it changes: it trims the novel’s longer satirical asides and backstories, keeping the pace at a swashbuckling sprint.
Watch or read first? Film first — it’s ninety-eight minutes of pure joy. Then read the book for the extra jokes and Goldman’s pretend “abridgement” framing.
2. The Shawshank Redemption (1994) — Stephen King
Yes, that Stephen King — and no, this isn’t horror. The film adapts King’s novella Rita Hayworth and Shawshank Redemption, a quiet story about hope, friendship, and time inside a prison.
What it keeps: the novella’s soul — the narration, the long patience of the central friendship, and its belief that hope is a discipline, not a mood. What it changes: it expands a few supporting characters, deepens one beloved prisoner’s storyline into the film’s emotional high point, and gives the ending a visual openness the page could only describe.
Watch or read first? Either works beautifully. The novella is short enough for a weekend, and reading it first makes the film’s small expansions feel like gifts.
3. The Lord of the Rings Trilogy (2001–2003) — J. R. R. Tolkien
One entry, three films: The Fellowship of the Ring (2001), The Two Towers (2002), and The Return of the King (2003), Peter Jackson’s adaptation of Tolkien’s vast novel.
What it keeps: the heart of the book — the smallness of the hobbits against an enormous war, the weight of the Ring, and long passages of Tolkien’s language, lifted into dialogue with obvious reverence. What it changes: plenty, and honestly. Whole characters and detours are cut, timelines are compressed, and a few characters get more visible inner conflict than they have on the page.
Watch or read first? If the novel’s size intimidates you, watch the films first; they’re a magnificent map of the story. Then read the book for everything the films had no room for — songs, histories, and a slower, richer Middle-earth.
4. Pride and Prejudice (2005) — Jane Austen
Austen has been adapted endlessly, but the 2005 film, directed by Joe Wright, is the one I’d hand a newcomer.
What it keeps: Austen’s wit, often in her own words, Elizabeth Bennet’s sharp tongue, Mr Darcy’s disastrous pride, and the slow, charged build between the leads. What it changes: it makes the world muddier, livelier, and more visually romantic — grand houses give way to working farms and crowded dances, and manners are translated into glances modern audiences read instantly.
Watch or read first? Read the book first if you can; it’s funnier than its reputation suggests. But the film is a completely respectable doorway to Austen.
5. Gone Girl (2014) — Gillian Flynn
Another author who adapted her own work: Gillian Flynn wrote the screenplay for the film of her bestselling novel about a marriage, a disappearance, and two very unreliable storytellers. Because this entry depends on twists, I’ll stay carefully vague.
What it keeps: the structure. The film preserves the book’s shifting perspectives and its cold, clever examination of how couples perform for each other and for the public. What it changes: some interior monologue becomes visual detail and performance, and a few subplots are tightened, making the story arguably colder and sharper. Flynn reworked the final stretch for the screen; the destination feels familiar to readers, the route slightly less so.
Watch or read first? Pick one, commit, and don’t let anyone discuss either near you. Both are excellent, and Flynn’s dialogue alone makes the other worth it afterwards.
6. Little Women (2019) — Louisa May Alcott
Greta Gerwig’s adaptation of Alcott’s beloved 1868 novel about the four March sisters might be the cleverest film on this list, because its biggest change is structural.
What it keeps: the warmth, the quarrels, the ambitions, and Alcott’s insistence that each sister’s path deserves respect. What it changes: instead of the book’s straight line, the film moves between the sisters’ childhood and adult lives, letting past and present comment on each other. It also leans into Alcott’s own negotiation with her publishers, giving the ending a layer the novel could only hint at.
Watch or read first? Film first is a delight with no background needed. Readers get an extra pleasure: watching a faithful film rearrange scenes they know by heart into something newly true.
7. Dune (2021) — Frank Herbert
Frank Herbert’s Dune was called unfilmable for decades — too dense, too political, too interior. Denis Villeneuve’s 2021 film solves the problem with patience and scale.
What it keeps: the novel’s gravity. The ecology, the politics, the sense that young Paul Atreides is walking into forces far older than himself — all of it survives, conveyed through sound, design, and silence as much as dialogue. What it changes: this film covers roughly the first half of the novel, so it simplifies and defers a great deal, and some characters get less room than readers will expect.
Watch or read first? Honestly, film first this time. The movie gives you faces, places, and pronunciations that make Herbert’s dense opening chapters far easier to enter — then the book rewards you with the full depth.
So, Book or Film First?
There’s no rule. Start with whichever medium you actually enjoy, because a great adaptation is not a replacement for its book — it’s a conversation with it. Watching first can make a daunting classic welcoming; reading first can make a film feel like a reunion.
One last suggestion: if younger viewers are joining movie night, our picks for animated movies adults will love just as much as kids are every bit as carefully made as the films above. However you order them, I hope this list sends you to a bookshop and a sofa in equal measure. That’s the real test of the best book to movie adaptations: you finish the film, and immediately want the book.

